Criminal Defense Attorney Valparaiso & Valparaiso Family Law Lawyer
call: (219) 575-8565
Appeals and Post-Conviction Relief
I wanted to express my sincere gratitude to Mark and your wonderful secretary for the exceptional care and kindness you’ve shown me. Despite the challenges posed by my illness, which have made communication more difficult, Mark has demonstrated remarkable patience and understanding.
Northwest Indiana Appeals and Post-Conviction Relief Lawyer
A criminal conviction can feel like you’ve reached the end of your legal road. The heavy burden of a guilty verdict and the fear of what comes next can completely overwhelm you and your family. However, an initial trial court decision is not always the final word in a criminal case. The legal system recognizes that judges, prosecutors, and even defense lawyers can make mistakes.
If you believe your trial was unfair or your constitutional rights were violated, Indiana law provides powerful ways to challenge the outcome, including direct appeals and post-conviction relief. These legal remedies exist to correct errors and seek true justice. At Worthley Law, we can guide you through these processes, all the while fighting to protect your future.
The Purpose of Appeals in Criminal Law
A direct appeal is a formal request asking a higher court to review the trial court’s decision. You must file this request within a short window after your conviction and sentencing. The primary goal of an appeal is to demonstrate that significant legal errors occurred during your trial, and that these errors negatively impacted the final outcome. An appeals court does not hear new evidence or question new witnesses; instead, appellate judges carefully review the existing trial record, transcripts, and legal briefs submitted by your lawyer.
During an appeal, we look for critical mistakes in the original trial record, like a judge allowing improper evidence to be shown to the jury or imposing a sentence that exceeds legal limits. If the higher court agrees that a major error occurred, they have the power to reverse your conviction or send your case back to the lower court for a new trial.
A Second Option: Exploring Post-Conviction Relief
Post-conviction relief is a separate legal process used to challenge a conviction or sentence. Unlike an appeal, this kind of petition allows you to bring forward new facts and evidence that were not presented during your original trial. This approach is essential for addressing serious issues that happened outside the official court record. Common reasons to file for post-conviction relief include:
- Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Your previous trial lawyer failed to do their job properly, depriving you of a fair trial.
- Newly Discovered Evidence: New facts, such as updated forensic testing, may have emerged that prove your innocence.
- Prosecutorial Misconduct: The state hid evidence that could have helped your defense or violated your Constitutional rights.
A successful post-conviction relief petition can lead to a vacated conviction, an altered sentence, or a completely new trial.
Worthley Law Can Defend Your Rights
Both the appellate system and post-conviction rules require significant legal experience and a meticulous, strategic approach. We know the anxiety and stress you carry when your freedom is on the line. Our team is here to provide the comprehensive support you need, ensuring you are never alone in this journey.
When you come to us after receiving an unjust conviction, our criminal defense lawyer will review your trial and circumstances to determine the best approach for your case, whether submitting an appeal or a petition for post-conviction relief. We explain every step in clear, simple terms, prioritizing your understanding and mental well-being just as much as your legal defense. Our focus remains on building a strategy designed to protect your reputation, mitigate penalties, and secure the best possible outcome.
Secure the Legal Support You Need Today
The justice system is powerful, but not infallible. You do not have to simply accept an unjust outcome. If you need legal support after a criminal conviction, contact Worthley Law for a confidential consultation. We will evaluate your case, explain your legal options, and stand with you every step of the way to make your voice heard.
What Our Real
Clients Are saying
I wanted to express my sincere gratitude to Mark and your wonderful secretary for the exceptional care and kindness you’ve shown me. Despite the challenges posed by my illness, which have made communication more difficult, Mark has demonstrated remarkable patience and understanding.
Mark is more than just an exceptional lawyer! He is someone who truly cares about the people he represents. He did not just help me fight my case the right way but he helped me see things the right way. Throughout the entire process, Mark guided me with honesty, integrity and patience, often stepping into a role that felt more like a father figure than just legal counsel. He challenged me when I needed it, supported me when things felt overwhelming and always kept my best interests at heart. I am incredibly grateful not only for the outcome of my case but for the perspective and growth I gained because of his guidance. If you are looking for a lawyer who genuinely invests in you as a person, not just a case number, Mark is the one!
If you are looking for an attorney who will do what they say they are going to do and keep you informed and updated every step of the way, this is the attorney for you! I highly recommend working with Mark Worthley and his team of professionals! Thank you very much, Mark!
Mark provided exceptional support during my time of need, demonstrating a high level of helpfulness and expertise. I wholeheartedly recommend him and his team.
Mark and Tara are an awesome team. Mark handled a case for me and got me a more than fair deal. Tara was my lawyer for my divorce and she is nothing short of amazing and compassionate. They cared about what was best for my family and helped me every step of the way. You’re in good hands with the Worthley family law practice. They have excellent prices and are more than willing to work with you. You can tell they are genuinely there to help.
After multiple referrals, I was referred to Mark Worthley and I am very glad I was. He did such a great job with my case and obtained for me the best possible outcome which I am eternally grateful for. Almost no words can express how grateful I am to have him on my case. He was very diligent and patient with my case and he will fight for his clients to have the best possible outcomes no matter the costs or the duration- he will go the extra mile for you. He displayed a wealth of knowledge on all things law, displayed professionalism, trustworthiness, level headedness, patience, and kindness during the worst of times that can befall on a person. I would highly recommend anyone to Mark in need of legal help! I one hundred percent recommend!!!
Worthley Law is the premier law firm in Northwest Indiana. Always attentive to their customers and very knowledgeable of all things law.
I am gonna be honest. I see alot of review for Mark on here which in my opinion is a great lawyer, but the lawyer that I haven't seen reviews on is Tara Worthley. Going through stressful cases like custody can be a absolute nightmare. Especially with the wrong representation. It is something that can tear a person to pieces but the guidance and compassion and assistance Tara Worthley, provided was unlike any other. I am still going through my process and whichever way it goes in my situation. I know she fought to the very end and represented me in a very professional manner. What I like about Tara is she is very calm and humble but knows facts . She is a fantastic lawyer, highly recommend to anyone going through a stressful case like custody.
Going through stressful cases like custody can be an absolute nightmare. Especially with the wrong representation. It is something that can tear a person to pieces but the guidance and compassion and assistance Tara Worthley, provided was unlike any other. I am still going through my process and whichever way it goes in my situation. I know she fought to the very end and represented me in a very professional manner. What I like about Tara is she is very calm and humble but knows facts. She is a fantastic lawyer, highly recommend to anyone going through a stressful case like custody.
I highly recommend Mark for your legal needs. He worked diligently on our case and obtained a best possible outcome. He brings a wealth of experience to his representation, which allows him to clearly discuss the situation, potential outcomes, and best actions to take to reach a successful result. We could not be more satisfied with Mark's representation.
Schedule Your Consultation
Today
Attorney Advertising. This information is designed for general information only. The information presented should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. Past results and testimonials are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of your case, and should not be construed as such. Past results cannot guarantee future performance. Any result in a single case is not meant to create an expectation of similar results in future matters because each case involves many different factors, therefore, results will differ on a case-by-case basis. By providing contact information, users acknowledge and give explicit consent to be contacted via the methods of communication provided, including SMS. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. Reply STOP to opt out.
NUVEW | Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved | Accessibility Notice | Privacy Policy